It gives a little when the sphincter is contracted, encouraging the bottom to “fight” the plug, which increases the sensation and opens the anus. Butt plugs, however, do exactly what you'd imagine: They plug up your butt. A butt plug's main duty is to make you feel good: "The anus can be. Hollow butt plug or Tunnel Butt plugs - Are you bored with your regular sex life? Perfect Tunnel Anal Plug are perfect if you wish to experience deepened.